TIP:
*If you can’t find “Frisbee”, search for “Flying Disc” instead
*If you can’t find “Pet Toy” or “Chew Toy”, search for “Throw Toy” instead
| Toy | Name | Rarity | Value | From |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Heart Rattle | Common | 143 | Valentine’s Event 2019 |
 | Squid Plush | Common | 100 | Gifts |
 | Pumpkin Rattle | Common | 86 | Halloween Event 2017 |
 | Creepy Balloon | Common | 76 | Halloween Event 2019 |
 | Horse Plush | Common | 76 | Gifts |
 | Llama Plush | Common | 76 | Gifts |
 | Reindeer Plush | Common | 76 | Gifts |
 | Rabbit Rattle | Common | 62 | Easter Event 2019 |
 | Bauble Balloon | Common | 53 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Heart Plushie | Common | 53 | Valentine’s Event 2018 |
 | Puppy Plush | Common | 53 | Gifts |
 | Banana Plush | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Cat Plush | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Caticorn Rattle | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Croc Plush | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Elephant Plush | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Marsh Plush | Common | 48 | Gifts |
 | Christmas Doge Rattle | Common | 43 | Christmas Event 2017 |
 | Gift Throw Toy | Common | 43 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Sock Chew Toy | Common | 43 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Flower Rattle | Common | 34 | Gifts |
 | Polar Bear Plush | Common | 34 | Gifts |
 | Santa Leash | Common | 34 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Chew Ball | Common | 22 | Gifts |
 | Elf Plush | Common | 22 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Snowball Launcher | Common | 22 | Winter Holiday Event 2020 |
 | Candle | Common | 19 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Candy Cane Ornament | Common | 19 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Cookie Dough Plush | Common | 19 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Rubber Bone Throw Toy | Common | 19 | Pet Shop |
 | Snowman Plush | Common | 19 | Gifts |
 | Sunflower Rattle | Common | 19 | Spring Festival Event 2020 |
 | Flying Disc Umbrella | Common | 17 | Gifts |
 | Turkey Leg | Common | 17 | Gifts |
 | Cactus Plushie Chew Toy | Common | 12 | Gifts |
 | Eyeball Rattle | Common | 12 | Halloween Event 2020 |
 | Heart Balloon | Common | 12 | Toy Shop |
 | Galaxy Flying Disc | Common | 10 | Gifts |
 | Rattle | Common | 10 | Baby Shop |
 | T-Rex Rattle | Common | 10 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Venus Fly Trap Rattle | Common | 10 | Gifts |
 | Claw | Common | 4 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Dog Food Flying Disc | Common | 4 | Gifts |
 | Doge Rattle | Common | 4 | Baby Shop |
 | Ice Cream Rattle | Common | 4 | Gifts |
 | Long Neck Throw Toy | Common | 4 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Peppermint Disc | Common | 4 | Winter Holiday Event 2020 |
 | Potion Bottle Balloon | Common | 4 | Halloween Event 2022 |
 | Soccer Ball Throw Toy | Common | 4 | Gifts |
 | Stegosaurus Throw Toy | Common | 4 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | T-Rex Throw Toy | Common | 4 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Duck Rattle | Common | 2 | Baby Shop |
 | Inner Tube | Common | 2 | Pool Store |
 | Lead Zeppelin Balloon | Common | 2 | Gifts |
 | Pogo Stick | Common | 2 | Toy Shop |
 | Spider Web Flying Disc | Common | 2 | Halloween Event 2022 |
 | Stick Throw Toy | Common | 2 | Gifts |
 | Teddy Bear | Common | 2 | Toy Shop |
 | Zombie Finger Rattle | Common | 2 | Halloween Event 2022 |
 | Banana Rattle | Common | 1 | Baby Shop |
 | Celestial Leash | Common | 1 | Gifts |
 | Floaties | Common | 1 | Pool Store |
 | Floppy Bunny Plushie | Common | 1 | Toy Shop |
 | Huggable Pillow | Common | 1 | Gifts |
 | Lazy Float | Common | 1 | Pool Store |
 | Pool Noodle | Common | 1 | Pool Store |
 | Raw Bone | Common | 1 | Pet Shop |
 | Shoe Chew Toy | Common | 1 | Pet Shop |
 | Soda Chew Toy | Common | 1 | Gifts |
 | Squeaky Bone | Common | 1 | Pet Shop |
 | Star Balloon | Common | 1 | Toy Shop |
 | Sun Balloon | Common | 1 | Gifts |
 | Christmas Ornament | Common | 0 | Unknown |
 | Dumbbell | Common | 0 | Unknown |
 | Icicle Throw Toy | Common | 0 | Unknown |
 | Standard Pogo | Common | 0 | Toy Shop |
 | Voting Paddle | Common | 0 | Unknown |
 | Musical Conch | Common | Untradeable | Oceans Day Stand |