TIP:
*If you can’t find “Frisbee”, search for “Flying Disc” instead
*If you can’t find “Pet Toy” or “Chew Toy”, search for “Throw Toy” instead
| Toy | Name | Rarity | Value | From |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Rainbow Rattle | Rare | 359,100 | Gifts |
 | Tombstone Ghostify | Rare | 1,235 | Halloween Event 2018 |
 | Hugging Egg | Rare | 300 | Easter Event 2018 |
 | Teddy Skele | Rare | 205 | Halloween Event 2017 |
 | Elf Ornament | Rare | 100 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Fancy Umbrella | Rare | 95 | Gifts |
 | Pumpkin | Rare | 86 | Halloween Event 2017 |
 | Ferris Wheel Propeller | Rare | 76 | Halloween Event 2019 |
 | Jackhammer | Rare | 76 | Gifts |
 | Noob Balloon | Rare | 76 | Gifts |
 | Rocket Pogo | Rare | 76 | Gifts |
 | Chick Plush | Rare | 62 | Easter Event 2019 |
 | Christmas Cat Rattle | Rare | 62 | Gifts |
 | Duck Balloon | Rare | 53 | Gifts |
 | Marsh Balloon | Rare | 53 | Gifts |
 | Monkey Pogo | Rare | 53 | Monkey Box Premium Monkey Box |
 | Chocolate Bunny Balloon | Rare | 48 | Easter Event 2019 |
 | Star & Moon Propeller | Rare | 48 | Halloween Event 2020 |
 | Telescope Pogo | Rare | 48 | Gifts |
 | Crown Flying Disc | Rare | 34 | Gifts |
 | Kangaroo Pogo | Rare | 34 | Gifts |
 | Reindeer Leash | Rare | 34 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Sleigh Bells Rattle | Rare | 34 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Donut Flying Disc | Rare | 22 | Gifts |
 | Easter Bunny Plush | Rare | 22 | Easter Event 2019 |
 | Wreath Flying Disc | Rare | 22 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Pink Cat Balloon | Rare | 19 | Gifts |
 | Snowflake Flying Disc | Rare | 19 | Christmas Event 2019 |
 | Spider Grappling Hook | Rare | 19 | Halloween Event 2020 |
 | Bone Xylophone | Rare | 17 | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Cactus Grappling Hook | Rare | 17 | Gifts |
 | Magical Princess Leash | Rare | 17 | Gifts |
 | Briefcase Ingredient | Rare | 15 | Monkey Box Premium Monkey Box |
 | Cymbal Ingredient | Rare | 15 | Monkey Box Premium Monkey Box |
 | Lunar Pogo | Rare | 15 | Lunar New Year Event 2021 |
 | Rose Pogo | Rare | 15 | Gifts |
 | Didgeridoo | Rare | 12 | Star Rewards |
 | Frostbite Grapple | Rare | 12 | Star Rewards |
 | Da Vinci Propeller | Rare | 10 | Star Rewards |
 | Rubber Chicken Rattle | Rare | 10 | Gifts |
 | Spinning Propeller | Rare | 10 | Toy Shop |
 | Dog Leash | Rare | 4 | Gifts |
 | Guitar | Rare | 4 | Camping Store |
 | Magic Wand Grappling Hook | Rare | 4 | Gifts |
 | Skull Propeller | Rare | 4 | Halloween Event 2022 |
 | Clouds & Rainbow Rattle | Rare | 2 | Baby Shop |
 | Pizza Float | Rare | 2 | Pool Store |
 | Potato Chew Toy | Rare | 2 | Gifts |
 | Propeller | Rare | 2 | Toy Shop |
 | Rope Chew Toy | Rare | 2 | Gifts |
 | Space Grappling Hook | Rare | 2 | Gifts |
 | Balloon | Rare | 1 | Gifts |
 | Star Ball | Rare | 1 | Pet Shop |
 | Football Throw Toy | Rare | 0 | Pet Shop |
 | Fossil | Rare | 0 | Unknown |